Indie bookstores

What's going on with the fortunes of independent bookstores? I noticed seemingly conflicting reports on the sector--particularly in Chicago--on two Chicago-based blogs this week.

Wednesday, Pete Lit eulogized the soon-to-be shuttered Brent Books here.

Then yesterday, at The Outfit, Sara Paretsky remarked on various indications of vitality in the business.

These reports aren't necessarily contradictory: Pete points out that Brent Books was not adequately serving those who wanted to shop there, while Sara indicates that her favored indies are more energetic and attentive.

Still, the contrast caught my eye.

--Marshal Zeringue