Sunday, November 22, 2026

Six notable books with unreliable narrators

Born and raised in New York City, Rachel Calnek-Sugin is a writer, social worker, and educator committed to our individual and collective liberation through art-making, community building, and personal transformation. She loves trees, dancing down the streets of Brooklyn, and cooking extravagant meals for her loved ones. She works as a therapist in New York City's public schools and writes fiction, nonfiction, plays, and the occasional subway-poem.

Universe of Grace is her first novel.

At Lit Hub Calnek-Sugin tagged some of her "favorite unreliable narrator fiction—by which I mean, novels whose distinctive narration explores themes of trust and subjectivity—in ways that trouble ideas about what’s real, who’s sane, and what gets lost in the telling of the story." One title on the list:
Kazuo Ishiguro, Remains of the Day

This is one of the most quietly devastating novels I’ve ever read. Remains of the Day features an old-school butler named Stevens in postwar England reflecting on things like dignity and what it takes be a great butler. It’s a slow, meticulous unraveling that rewards a patient reader. Stevens recollects his decades of devoted work for Lord Darlington, who he insists is noble, righteous, above any criticism. As we learn more about Stevens’ former employer, it slowly becomes clear that he was an influential Nazi sympathizer—but our narrator is blinded by continuing to cling to a story that’s falling part, because it made his life feel meaningful and virtuous. Stevens’ commitment to hard work, dignity, and emotional detachment also lead to agonizing relationships with both his father and his potential love interest, Miss Kenton—agonizing for us, I mean; Stevens himself insists on living in an infuriatingly rational register, rather than an emotional one. It’s this self-denial, and attempt at self-discipline, that makes him such a compelling unreliable narrator. One of my mentors, Dan, once told me that a tragedy is a story where the main character realizes too late what could have made their life meaningful. Remains of the Day is a real tragedy by that measure. The last few pages absolutely wrenched me. And they were also a call to be real with myself.
Read about another entry on the list.

The Remains of the Day is among Jonny Sweet's four best country house novels, Emily Temple's seven great love stories for cynics, Sung J. Woo’s five top mysterious classic novels that take place in a grand manor house, Saumya Roy's seven books about star-crossed lovers, A. Natasha Joukovsky's seven novels that subvert social norms, Mark Skinner's ten best country house novels, Xan Brooks's ten top terrible houses in fiction, Molly Schoemann-McCann's nine great books for people who love Downton Abbey, Lucy Lethbridge's ten top books about servants, and Tim Vine's six best books.

--Marshal Zeringue